Wikipedia:Peer review/Historical background of the New Testament/archive1

Cultural and historical background of Jesus

Having NPOV problems here. Could a non-Christian non-non-Christian please take a look at it? CheeseDreams 23:47, 2 Nov 2004 (UTC)

• Took a look, added comments, and wished for this to be written in Japanese, my native language, from the headache looking at unfamiliar phrases. I can't comment on f or j as reasons are not offered. BTW, I'm Shinto-Buddhism and is a non-Christian. Revth 01:47, 4 Nov 2004 (UTC)

A recent development is that I have noticed Slrubenstein is trying to bring people (via their talk pages) whom he sees as supporters of his POV into the discussion (see his contributions list). I do not think this is a very NPOV thing to do. I would like a variety of people from different points of view/NPOV to please comment on the issues on the talk page (at the base), so that weight of numbers dilute his what-I-Would-See-As Gerrymandering?

By the way, I think being Shinto-Buddhist is a good thing for commenting on the article, as I think you will be indifferent to taking sides, therefore more Neutral. CheeseDreams 00:36, 5 Nov 2004 (UTC)

What are you claiming is my point of view? Slrubenstein 18:00, 29 Jan 2005 (UTC)

By the way, peer-review should not be based on whether someone is a Christian or not; it should be based on how much of the recent scholarship on the subject they know. Slrubenstein 18:00, 29 Jan 2005 (UTC)